An Atherton Paulée: From 1900 Madeira to Coche-Dury Blind
There are carefully planned wine dinners, where every bottle has its place in the sequence and everything proceeds in a sensible order. And then there are evenings when all plans eventually give way to glorious chaos. This one began with a private recital in Atherton, followed by an extraordinary evening of wine among a group of serious wine lovers. There was no formal tasting lineup. Bottles were simply opened and shared, initially with something resembling a logical progression and later with increasingly little regard for appellation, vintage or conventional serving order. It gradually turned into something resembling a miniature Paulée . Champagne gave way to white Burgundy, then mature Burgundy, Rhône and California. But eventually bottles simply started materializing. A La Turque suddenly appeared. Then more Burgundy. Champagne returned. A 1900 Madeira entered the picture. An 1868 Armagnac followed. And just when the evening surely had to be over, the host produced a mystery whit...